Unburdened by false humility, postmodern trauma activists claim to have understood for the first time what drives all of human suffering
Trauma DispatchTrauma news you can't get anywhere else. |
|
|
CATEGORY: GOVERNMENT PROJECTS: CITY  Wendy Ellis, Dr.P.H., Assistant Professor, George Washington University Source: WCPO ABC 9 news Read time: 1.7 minutes This Happened On April 2, 2024, a committee of the Cincinnati City Council hosted a presentation titled Building Equitable & Resilient Neighborhoods. This was the latest step in a process over recent years by a coalition of community leaders demanding government action for large-scale systemic change by trying to address stress and trauma as underlying causes of inequity in child outcomes. Who Did This? The coalition consists of Cincinnati Children’s Hospital, the University of Cincinnati, and George Washington University’s Center for Community Resilience. The group presentation was led by Wendy Ellis, Assistant Professor at George Washington University. Her 2019 dissertation was a model that conceptualizes adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) as outcomes of systems driven by institutional racism; and these outcomes, including racial disparities in evictions, income inequity, and economic mobility, must be addressed through public health initiatives. The Premise The coalition is trying to press city government to adopt new policies and enact reforms aimed at addressing trauma because they assert those cause inequities in child well-being outcomes. Their language tends to emphasize trauma, but their model includes everyday stress experiences—household disruption, parental incarceration, food insecurity, and poverty—that are not life-threatening trauma. Proposed reforms include to alleviate poverty (cash assistance, child tax credits), increase entitlements (preschool and childcare), educate children on relationship skills, educate parents on how to parent, provide mentoring and after-school programs, and teach everyone about the ACEs narrative.
Analysis Consistent with the postmodern trauma activism of the past several decades that draws extraordinary causal interpretations from shaky science, these ACEs models claim to understand for the first time in history what drives nearly all human suffering. It cannot be overemphasized that supporters of ACE movements intend large-scale expansion of entitlements and government power. Their intent is to “transform,” as the subtitle of the presentation stated: “Vision: Transform the City of Cincinnati into a national beacon of healing, community resilience, and racial justice by centering the experiences and interests of trauma exposed children and families in organizational planning, partnerships, and policies.” Philadelphia, Baltimore, New Orleans, and other cities have embarked on similar public health models based on the ACEs narrative. Each are different in details and stage of implementation, but none have achieved major success. No reports from these models have provided evidence that these strategies work. It is unlikely the programs can work because the ACE research on which they are built is controversial and unproven. Dr. Ellis says “The science is clear,” but she and other ACE supporters seem unaware that all ACE research comes from cross-sectional studies that have zero power to prove causative links. Another concern, besides the science, is that none of this reform for large-scale culture shift has been adequately presented to or voted on by the public, who are mostly unaware of what is happening. Like Trauma Dispatch? You can subscribe to our email notices of new posts on this page. Comments are closed.
|
